Why the leaders growing fastest are using both.
Here’s something I hear more and more from coaching and mentoring clients:
“I brain dumped into [generative] AI and it actually helped me organize my thoughts and gave me something usable.”
And they’re right. AI is incredibly good at helping you organize your thinking, generate options, and get unstuck quickly.
These tools can surface new angles, unblock momentum, prompt useful reflection, and meet you exactly where you are when you’re spiraling about a decision.
That’s genuinely valuable.
But here’s what shows up consistently, in session and after:
There’s a kind of progress that happens in a real conversation that doesn’t happen anywhere else... not all the time, but in very specific moments when it matters most.
Saying It Out Loud Changes Everything
I work with a CMO who has a standing mentoring session with me each week. Not for strategy decks or performance reviews, rather to talk through whatever is blocking them or rattling around in their head.
I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve heard some version of:
“OK, just saying that out loud… I already know what I need to do.”
It’s a pattern I’ve written about before: how simply getting thoughts out of your head and into the open changes the way you see them.
That’s not a coaching trick. That’s what happens when a real human being is on the other end of the conversation, someone who will ask you about it next week, who knows what you said three months ago, and who can tell when your energy has shifted even if your words haven’t.
The Difference: Insight and Accountability
Insight can inform action. Accountability drives it.
This isn’t a knock on AI as a thinking tool. It belongs in the toolbox, but the toolbox also needs people. Humans with lived experience, genuine curiosity, and a stake in your growth.
There is a meaningful difference between thinking something through privately and saying it out loud to someone who will follow up, push back, and hold you to what you said you wanted.
Clarity matters, but what you do after you have it matters more, especially for your own growth.
A Better Question
Rather than asking whether AI can replace a coach or mentor, a better question is:
What does each one do well, and am I benefiting from using both?
AI is remarkable at scale, speed, and availability.
Human coaching is remarkable at accountability, relationship, and the kind of challenge that actually changes behavior.
If you’re using AI, the real advantage isn’t just what it gives you. It’s how you engage with it: what you question, what you recognize as right or off, and what you realize you already knew.
The leaders I see growing the fastest aren’t choosing between the two. They’re intentionally using both. They aren’t outsourcing their thinking, rather using every tool available to sharpen it and to actually develop.
Leave a Reply